From the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
An emergency childbirth on the side of Route 219 in Elk County, four months after the closing of the maternity unit at the nearest hospital, is stoking health care worries in the sparsely populated county, 2½ hours northeast of Pittsburgh.
Ridgway Ambulance Corp. paramedic Missy Lecker, 54, and her crew delivered a healthy baby girl on the side of the road Sept. 24, when it became clear they were not going to make it to Penn Highlands Healthcare’s maternity hospital in Clearfield County, about 29 miles from where the call was received.
“She was in labor,” Ms. Lecker said about the 27-year-old mother. “Her water had broken.”
Penn Highlands, which reported an operating loss of $36.4 million for the year ending June 30, closed the maternity unit at its St. Marys hospital in May.
“Unfortunately, this is becoming way too commonplace with the closure of Penn Highlands Elk maternity,” the ambulance service posted on its Facebook page. Ms. Lecker declined further comment.
A Penn Highlands spokeswoman said the hospital system had no plans to reopen the closed unit at the St. Marys hospital or create a freestanding birthing center alternative for moms-to-be.
Operating losses for the eight-hospital, DuBois-based system for fiscal years ending June 30 in 2023 and 2024 totaled $68.7 million, spurring a Fitch Ratings bond issuer default and revenue bond ratings cut to BBB from A-minus in August.
Elk County is part of a six-county swath of the state — twice the size of Delaware — that has no hospital maternity care, which concerns Ridgway Borough Council member Zack Pontious, who has met with Penn Highlands officials to discuss its decision to end obstetrics services at the local hospital.
“A more vibrant, community-minded health care delivery system delivers high-quality care, even for the most basic medical needs,” he said. “We do not have that in Elk County today.”
In response, a group of local residents and business owners have formed the Elk County HealthCare Coalition, with the aim of creating an independent, countywide authority that would find ways of enhancing health care services. The county commissioners will conduct a public hearing on the proposal to create the Elk County Health Care Authority on Oct. 11.
“It did seem the idea had merit,” Elk County Commissioner Matthew G. Quesenberry said. “It’s an idea worth pursuing. They’ve got their facts together.”
The Penn Highlands spokeswoman said the health care system would continue consulting with county commissioners on the creation of the authority, but said it was premature to say whether the discussions would result in a partnership.
Elk County has a population of just 31,000, smaller than some Pittsburgh-area townships, which includes 4,500 women between the childbearing ages of 15 and 44, according to the U.S. Census.
Rural residents generally face poorer health outcomes from cancer, heart problems and other chronic diseases while rural hospitals often face bigger fiscal challenges than their urban counterparts, according to KFF Health News, a San Francisco nonprofit.
Rural health care providers often face bigger fiscal challenges than their urban counterparts, according to KFF, while studies have shown wide disparities in longevity and how well patients do in recovering from chronic diseases, depending on whether they live in rural or urban areas.
Between 2010 and 2019, 114 rural hospitals eliminated inpatient services or closed altogether while others cut specific service lines, such as obstetrics. In 2019, the year before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, median operating margins at rural hospitals were 1.5%, which compared to 5.2% among other hospitals.
In addition to maternity care, Mr. Pontious said a health care authority could try to find physicians and other partners and solutions for a variety of health care issues in the county, including expanding primary care.
“We hear this mantra that rural health care doesn’t work,” Mr. Pontious said. “What’s interesting is that an independent authority could find creative ways to fill a number of health care gaps in the county.”
“Everything is on the table,” he said. “The problem is so big.”